Impact on the system and risks
The decisions that have been made up to this point do not only have an exclusively technical impact.
$$
Technical failure? Financial loss (examples)
OPEX
Risk
| Typical fault |
What detonates in operation? |
Where does it stick in money? |
| Poorly coordinated protections |
Unnecessary shots/frequent resets |
Man-hours, scrap, downtime penalties and damage to critical equipment |
| Undersized capacity/redundancy |
Operation at the limit, without room for growth |
Unplanned corrective CAPEX + OPEX for shutdowns, overloads and reactive maintenance |
| Incomplete communications (SCADA/logging) |
“Operating blindly”, slow diagnosis and late decisions |
Longer recovery time (MTTR), site visits, loss of continuity and quality |
| Control logic without security criteria |
Missing interlocks, unsafe maneuvers, incidents |
HSE risk, fines, safety stoppages and accident costs |
These are typical examples. The actual quantification depends on your process, criticality, fees, penalties, and opportunity cost.
Technical note: values and effects are estimates; They must be validated with operational and financial data from the site.
From a perspective of Project ManagementThese decisions define critical variables that are of particular concern to Procurement, Engineering, Finance and Management, such as total costs, operational risks and business continuity and future flexibility.
In this context, there are fundamental dimensions to consider in decision making (Such as CAPEX and OPEX, among others)
The correct evaluation is not done in isolation, but rather considering their joint impact on the Total cost of ownership (TCO) and performance throughout their life cycle.
There are two fundamental concepts in the decision: CAPEX are decisions defining the system configuration (once); and OPEX materialised during operation (maintenance, efficiency, availability).
Decision moment: A significant proportion of the variables that impact OPEX, operational risks and TCO are defined during the conceptual, basic and integration engineering phases, prior to the acquisition of the main equipment.
Note: From Project Management, each layer contributes differently to the CAPEX of the project and to the OPEX of the operation. The following matrix summarizes how decisions made at each layer translate into economic and operational impacts throughout the system lifecycle.
Note: a significant proportion of OPEX is defined before acquiring the first team, as a direct result of design, architecture and integration decisions made during the project.
No technical layer mitigates these impacts or risks in isolation, it is the coherent integration of the system that determines the actual performance during the operation.
Key Executive Decisions
- Define the optimal system architecture
- Evaluate the project under a total cost of ownership (TCO) logic
- Ensure consistent integration between technical layers
Responsibility for these decisions
- Does not fall on a single team, supplier or discipline
- It is a comprehensive view of the system
- Validated from Project Management and Management
Risks
From Project Management, these risks do not usually originate in a single piece of equipment or technology, but in design, scope and integration decisions taken in early phases of the project, and manifest during operation.
!
Unscheduled shutdowns
Result of poor architectures and integrations between layers, directly affecting operational continuity and production commitments.
?
Risks to people
Consequence of unsafe maneuvers, non-selective protections and poorly defined operating logic, derived from insufficiently coordinated project decisions.
?
Impact on production
Loss of availability and high-impact electrical events that affect key business indicators, product quality and contract compliance.
?
Technical reprocessing
Late adjustments caused by unresolved interfaces during design, generating cost overruns, delays and deviations from the original plan.